Before he was killed last week, Charlie Kirk left a helpful compendium of words—ones that would greatly aid those who sought to understand his legacy and import. It is somewhat difficult to match these words with the manner in which Kirk is presently being memorialized in mainstream discourse.New York Times columnist Ezra Klein dubbed Kirk “one of the era’s most effective practitioners of persuasion” and a man who “was practicing politics in exactly the right way.” California governor Gavin Newsom hailed Kirk’s “passion and commitment to debate,” advising us to continue Kirk’s work by engaging “with each other, across ideology, through spirited discourse.”Atlantic writer Sally Jenkins saluted Kirk, claiming he “argued with civility” and asserting that his death was “a significant loss for those who believe engagement can help bridge disagreements.” The mentions of “debate” and “engagement” are references to Kirk’s campus tours, during which he visited various colleges to take on whoever come may. That this aspect of Kirk’s work would be so attractive to writers and politicians is understandable.
It’s no secret that Charlie Kirk trafficked in racist rhetoric at times, particularly during his associations with openly bigoted figures like Matt Walsh and Steven Crowder. That said, if you're going to label a self-proclaimed Christian like Kirk a "hatemonger," you need to cite concrete examples rather than rely on ad hominem attacks. Otherwise, you risk sounding like one of the many so-called race-baiters who exploit racial issues for personal or political gain, regardless of whether the racism in question is real or exaggerated. That said, with the recent Ezra Klein vs. Ta-Nehisi Coates discourse trending online, I think Klein (a committed liberal) has a point. After what happened last November, he seems to believe that Democrats need to take a page from Kirk’s playbook: start engaging with political opponents to find areas of common ground, rather than relying solely on anti-Trump rhetoric as a campaign strategy.














